NEWS ARCHIVE

Garnaut hands down draft carbon report

THE handing down last week of the draft Garnaut report into climate change signals the beginning ...

This article is 16 years old. Images might not display.

In the report, Ross Garnaut - economist and chairman of major mining company Lihir Gold - called for Australia to introduce a carbon trading scheme as soon as possible.

However, the report did not place any hard prices on carbon emissions, meaning the true economic impact is still unknown.

Beyond this, key points from Garnaut's 600-page report into the impacts of climate change and potential ways of mitigating those effects noted that transport should be included in an emissions trading scheme, energy costs will rise and coal-powered generation would not be given any compensation for having to foot a carbon tax.

However, the report also said it would be "in Australia's interest to find out as soon as possible whether there can be a low-emissions future for coal, and to support rapid deployment of commercially promising technologies", especially given Australia's status as the world's largest coal exporting nation.

Garnaut's report also suggested $A3 billion be spent, per year, on developing low emissions technology with Australia to become a market leader in the technology, especially in Asia.

The report is, at this stage, only one input into the Federal Labor Government's response to climate change and firm policy decisions on the size and shape of Australia's emissions trading scheme have yet to made.

"The review's first aim is to lay out the issues for policy choice in a transparent way. We will have done our job if Australian governments and the community make their choices in full knowledge of the consequences of their decisions," Garnaut said in a media statement.

Australian Petroleum Production & Exploration Association chief executive Belinda Robinson said the upstream oil and gas industry agreed that Australia's proposed greenhouse policy response had to be introduced in a consistent and coordinated way, and in a manner sensitive to the competitive position of Australia's exporters.

However, she said more work had to be done to ensure that policy recommendations are made on the basis of full and accurate information, and that exporters had the best means of transition as global negotiations continued.

The pipeline industry body welcomed Garnaut's recognition that base-load power generation is likely to be based on natural gas.

"In fact, Australia could meet its 2050 greenhouse target for electricity generation by moving all coal fired power generation to current natural gas technology," Australian Pipeline Industry Association chief executive Cheryl Cartwright said.

"However, it will be important to ensure that gas is available. Australia has abundant gas reserves, but these gas reserves need infrastructure in order to be delivered."

Other groups welcomed Garnaut's statement that he supported the phase out of mandatory emissions targets once a trading scheme was put into place.

The Queensland Resources Council said it favoured Garnaut's endorsement of research, development and commercialisation program into low-emission energy generation technologies.

However, the council's chief executive Michael Roche said that while the minerals and energy sector considered an emissions trading scheme the best way to price carbon, "trade-exposed emission intensive industries" such as coal mining and coal-fired power stations were also a "fundamental component" of the state's economy.

"An effective emissions trading scheme is the first step towards identifying how Australia can make the change from a carbon-intensive economy to a low-emissions economy without sacrificing the economic growth that will pay for these reforms," Roche said in a statement.

"Professor Garnaut's recommendation that additional mitigation policies should only be undertaken where they lower the overall cost to the economy is a strong acknowledgment that a mandatory renewable energy target is not in the country's long-term interests alongside an effective emissions trading scheme."

Australian Industry Group chief executive Heather Ridout said the group was in favour of emissions trading but the focus needed to be on achieving "least cost abatement".

"We also agree with the argument in the report that, until other countries impose equivalent costs on greenhouse gas emissions, Australia should adopt measures to ensure there is no loss of competitiveness on the part of Australia's trade exposed emissions intensive businesses," she said in a statement.

Ridout also said a gradual phasing in of emissions trading would be vital to giving business "breathing room" to adjust to new compliance regulations and additional costs.

Meanwhile, the leader of the opposition Dr Brendan Nelson said 2010 was too early for the introduction of an emissions trading scheme and could be economically dangerous.

"We think that it is most important that we get it right, that we protect Australian jobs, Australian industries ... in the process of developing this brand new system for our economy in dealing with climate change," Nelson told media in Sydney.

TOPICS:

A growing series of reports, each focused on a key discussion point for the energy sector, brought to you by the Energy News Bulletin Intelligence team.

A growing series of reports, each focused on a key discussion point for the energy sector, brought to you by the Energy News Bulletin Intelligence team.

editions

Energy News Bulletin Future of Energy Report 2024

With the global energy market in constant development, this report captures the sentiment of key industry players on the future of energy in Australia – and how it has changed through 2024.

editions

ENB CCS Report 2024

ENB’s CCS Report 2024 finds that CCS could be the much-needed magic bullet for Australia’s decarbonisation drive

editions

ENB Cost Report 2023

ENB’s latest Cost Report findings provide optimism as investments in oil and gas, as well as new energy rise.

editions

ENB Future of Energy Report 2023

ENB’s inaugural Future of Energy Report details the industry outlook on the medium-to-long-term future for the sector in the Asia Pacific region.